Why strategies fail to get implemented.
Published estimates put the failure rate between 50% and 90%. The usual explanations are communication and culture. In my experience the cause is earlier and simpler: who did the thinking.
Researchers have studied strategy failure for decades, and the estimates stay high: somewhere between half and nine in ten strategies do not deliver what they promised.
Over 25 years, more than 95% of the strategies executive teams have built with me have been implemented. That is not because I am good at selling ideas. It is because the team owns the thinking.
Where strategies go missing
- The team did not write it. A strategy delivered as a deck arrives as someone else's opinion. Executives nod, then go back to running the business they understand.
- It is not specific. "Grow the core" cannot be carried out. "Grow product A in market 2 by this much, owned by this person" can.
- Nothing was stopped. New priorities were added on top of old ones. The same people and the same budget now carry both.
- Nobody looked again. The strategy was approved in the autumn and next discussed a year later. Misses were explained, not fixed.
They build it, they believe it, and they carry it out.
What changes the odds
Four things, none of them complicated. The executive team answers the questions itself, in the room. Each choice is written by product and market, with a number and a name. Something is stopped to pay for what is started. And the page is reviewed against actuals on a regular rhythm, with the cause of each miss found and an action agreed before the meeting ends.
AI helps with the first of these more than people expect. When the analysis takes hours, the team's time goes to debating and deciding, and that is the part that creates ownership.
Sources: the 50% to 90% range is from published estimates, see Morgan et al., Journal of Business Research, 2025. The 95% figure is my own record over 25+ years of client work, as reported in MOVE (Routledge, 2025).
Implementation is decided when the strategy is written. If your team did not write it, do not expect them to deliver it.
Ask your team
What this idea asks of a company.
- Who wrote our current strategy?
- Can each executive name the three bets, and their part in them?
- What did we stop to fund it?
- When a number missed last quarter, did we find the cause or explain the variance?
One day with your executive team, before the 2027 plan is locked.
Your numbers, your team, one day in the room. A short note is enough to start.
Book a January session