SWOT is dead. What to use instead.
SWOT was built for the 1960s, when markets held still. It assumes your team agrees on what the threats and opportunities are. In my experience they rarely do.
You would not run your finances on software from the 1960s. Many companies still run strategy on a tool from the same decade.
SWOT did real work in its time. It gave structure to a messy conversation and made strategy teachable. I learned it in business school like everyone else. The trouble is the world it was designed for.
Three reasons it no longer holds
- It assumes agreement. A SWOT lists opportunities and threats as if the team sees the same ones. Ask five executives separately and you will often get five lists. That disagreement is the strategy problem, and SWOT hides it.
- It produces lists, not choices. Four boxes of bullet points do not say where the money goes or what stops. Nothing on the page has an owner or a number.
- It is a snapshot. It is filled in once a year, at the offsite, and filed. The market does not wait for the next one.
The danger is rarely a threat you listed. It is an assumption nobody said out loud.
What to use instead
Replace the four boxes with one page of assumptions. Five headings: customers, competitors, technology, regulation, and the things that will not change. Under each, the team writes what it believes is true about the next two to three years. Then it debates them, in the room, until the page is one the whole team will sign.
Each assumption gets three things SWOT does not ask for: the move it implies, the money it affects, and a trigger that tells you it has broken. When the trigger fires, you revisit the decision that month, not at the next offsite.
AI has made the first draft of this fast. It will size the market, map the competitors and list the forces in an afternoon. What it cannot do is decide which assumptions your team is prepared to bet on. That part is still people, in a room, with the right questions in the right order.
From MOVE: SWOT assumes we agree on what the opportunities and threats are. Two companies can read the same market data and build opposite strategies. The difference is the assumption, and invisible assumptions are the expensive ones.
If your strategy still starts with four boxes, start with what your team believes instead, and write down what would prove it wrong.
Ask your team
What this idea asks of a company.
- If each of us wrote our top three assumptions about the market separately, would the lists match?
- Which two assumptions carry most of the plan?
- What would we see first if one of them were wrong?
- Who is watching for it, and how often?
One day with your executive team, before the 2027 plan is locked.
Your numbers, your team, one day in the room. A short note is enough to start.
Book a January session