Porter's Five Forces is too slow for a fast market.
I studied Five Forces like everyone else, and liked it. It still explains an industry well. It no longer tells a CEO what to do on Monday.
Five Forces is one of the best pieces of thinking strategy has produced. It taught a generation of executives to look at suppliers, buyers, substitutes, entrants and rivals before committing capital. I still use the logic.
What has changed is the ground under it.
Where it breaks
- It assumes you know the industry. The framework starts by drawing a boundary. Apple was not a phone company until it was. Amazon was not a grocer until it bought Whole Foods. The competitor that hurts you is often outside the box you drew.
- It takes too long. A proper industry analysis used to take a team a quarter. By the time it was presented, the market had moved.
- It describes. It does not decide. You finish with a rich picture of the industry and no answer to where your next dollar goes.
The analysis is no longer the hard part. Deciding is.
What I do instead
The analysis itself is now fast. AI will run the five forces on your industry, and on the two industries next door, in an afternoon. So I spend the team's time on what comes after.
Three questions, in this order. Which products in which markets make our money today? Does outside evidence support the bets we are making in each one? And where do we have an advantage a competitor could not copy in a year?
The answers go on one page, by product and market, with a name beside each. Five Forces becomes an input to that page, which is where it belongs.
From MOVE, chapter 1: Traditional strategy tools assume that markets move predictably, that industry boundaries are stable and that planning cycles can keep up with the market. None of the three holds today.
Keep the thinking. Drop the three-month study. Use the time to decide.
Related: Five forces could not save Buffett →
Ask your team
What this idea asks of a company.
- Who could take our best customers without being in our industry today?
- How long does our competitive analysis take, and what decision did the last one change?
- In which product-market is our advantage hardest to copy?
- Which bet are we making without outside evidence?
One day with your executive team, before the 2027 plan is locked.
Your numbers, your team, one day in the room. A short note is enough to start.
Book a January session